Goodfellas Pizza Staten Island

Goodfellas Brick Oven Pizza

Goodfellas Pizza Staten Island

For Pizza Lovers who really know what great pizza is! The Original Goodfellas Pizza on Hylan Blvd in Staten Island, New York has been serving award-winning brick oven pizza ever since they opened in 1992. As a matter of fact the first year in business they were voted the “Best Pizza in America” at the Jacob Javits Center New York City. The Pizza they created was The Original  Vodka Pizza. Fresh Mozzarella, Vodka Sauce, fresh mushrooms peas and Prosciutto Di Parma. An amazing pizza that is still the best selling pizza on the menu!  Throughout the years Goodfellas has been a local Political Hotspot and Celebrity stop with every Mayor of New New York for the last 25 years stopping in and making Goodfellas their home base on Staten Island For Great Pizza. Goodfellas Pizza Staten Island

The Famous Vodka Pizza 

What makes Goodfellas  Pizza Staten Island great? 

Well, we could talk about the food (and we will) but the service and environment have always been upbeat- friendly and truly accommodating.  It’s a real good feel, good kind of place with regulars coming ever since the doors have opened. 

Goodfellas Pizza Staten Island

Pizza Lovers Pizza

Great Sevice and Great Food 

First of all, ingredients are fresh and made daily.  The Pizza dough is made with a family recipe that produces amazing pizza like no other.  The dough is aged for three days and made with a secret dough starter recipe. They grow there own yeast! 

Tomato sauce all blended by hand with the finest Italian Imported plum tomatoes money can buy, mixed with Extra Virgin olive oil, fresh chopped basil, and garlic. Now That’s a sauce.  

Fresh Mozzarella Handmade is the staple item on all pizzas. 

Goodfellas Pizza Staten Island

Small white mozzarella balls in a white dish with liquid.

Woodfired brick oven cooking!  Yes sir, cooking at 900 degrees makes an incredible pizza! 

Grated fresh imported pecorino tops all the pizzas adding amazing flavors and aromas! 

Goodfellas Pizza Staten Island

Grate It Daily


Fresh Pasta Dishes that are oversized and delicious, all made fresh to order! 

Goodfellas Pizza Staten Island

Woodfired Steaks all cut by hand and only prime cut beef! 

Steaks Staten Island Goodfellas

                 Prime Cuts Wood-fired

Great Bar Drinks 

Incredible Desserts, amazing homemade Tiramisu 

And amazing friendly service as always 

Check out our menu  HERE